Florida · Online practice · English & SpanishAdvisory only · Flat fees · No court

Second Opinion · One of Five Paths

An independent expert read on your Florida case whether it is pre-filing or pending in court.

A written analysis of your active divorce, custody, alimony, or post-judgment matter, delivered by a senior Florida family law attorney who will never take over your case. Flat fee. Conflict-free by design.

Book a Consultation →

The Second Opinion engagement begins with one 60-minute consultation · Flat fee $695 · Monthly Intake is capped · Credit toward the engagement signed within 48 hours

Miami-Dade · Broward · Florida Statewide Online · EN · ES

Independent. Flat fee. Never counsel of record.

Monthly intake is capped

Every Second Opinion is built around careful, unhurried attention to your matter, so the work is rationed by month. I accept no more than one Bespoke Second Opinion engagement per month, and no more than three standard Second Opinion engagements per month. The cap exists so that once you sign, the time the report needs is the time it gets.

If a deadline is on your calendar already, book the soonest open consultation slot. I will tell you at the consultation whether intake space exists for the turnaround you need.


What a Florida divorce Second Opinion is

A Second Opinion is a written, confidential review of your active Florida family law matter by a senior attorney who is not handling it. You hire me to do one job. Read everything. Tell you the truth about where your case stands, whether your lawyer’s strategy is benefitting them more than it is benefitting you, whether your strategy is effective, and whether the deal in front of you is one to sign or should you ask for more.

I do not call your current lawyer. I do not contact your spouse’s lawyer. I do not appear in court. I never take over your case. That structural independence is what makes the read worth getting.

The deliverable is a written report you own. Take it to mediation. Hand it to your counsel of record. Use it self-represented. The report does not evaporate when our calls end.


What you receive

Every Second Opinion engagement includes:

  • A written report covering issue map, posture analysis, settlement-range realism, and strategic options for the matter.
  • Two video calls with me, one mid-engagement and one after report delivery, to walk through what I found and what to do with it.
  • Conflict check and intake review before the engagement begins.
  • A portable, independent strategic asset that is yours to share or hold.

Who it is for

  • People with an active Florida family law matter, represented or self-represented, who want a senior attorney's independent read on strategy or settlement posture.
  • People preparing for mediation, deposition, or final hearing who want strategic preparation independent of their counsel of record.
  • People considering settlement who want a written sanity check on the numbers before they sign.
  • Self-represented Floridians weighing whether and how to file, who want an expert read before they walk into court alone.
  • People who sense something is off in their current representation but cannot point to what.
  • People whose current attorney may be doing fine, and who want that confirmed in writing by an independent expert.

Who it is not for

  • People hoping I will take over their case. I will not. The independence is the point.
  • People wanting me to communicate with opposing counsel, appear at a hearing, or file anything in court.
  • People in jurisdictions outside Florida. I am licensed to practice law in Florida only.

How it works

Step 1 · The 60-minute consultation. Every Second Opinion engagement begins at the consultation. We walk through your matter, I confirm a Second Opinion fits, and we agree on the flat fee and turnaround based on the documents and complexity in front of us. Flat fee $695. Credited in full toward the Second Opinion engagement if you sign within 48 hours.

Step 2 · Engagement letter and document upload. Within one business day of the consultation, you receive a written engagement letter with the flat fee, the scope, and the turnaround. Once signed and the retainer is paid, you upload the documents we identified.

Step 3 · The review. I read everything. Financial affidavits, the proposed marital settlement agreement, the parenting plan, the major discovery, the procedural posture. I run the numbers under current Florida law, including the 2023 alimony reform and the equal-timesharing presumption where they apply.

Step 4 · Mid-engagement call. A scheduled call partway through, to align on what I am seeing and confirm I have what I need.

Step 5 · Report delivery. A written report covering the issue map, the posture analysis, the settlement-range realism, and the strategic options. Yours to keep.

Step 6 · Debrief call. A scheduled call after the report lands, to walk through it together and answer questions about how to use it.


Fee structure

The Second Opinion engagement is a flat fee scoped at the consultation, based on document volume, complexity, and how much of your matter actually needs to be reviewed.

Standard range: $3,500 to $12,500 by depth band. Most matters land in this range. The fee is set in writing at the consultation. No hourly billing. No surprise add-ons.

Bespoke matters: quoted custom. Ultra simple or complex high-asset matters, matters with 350+ docket entries, multi-front motion practice, or a record that simply needs more depth are scoped and quoted as Bespoke at the consultation.

Expedited or Rush turnaround add-on. Standard delivery is 30 days. Faster lanes are available as flat-fee upcharges agreed at the consultation. See Turnaround below.

The $695 consultation fee credits in full toward the Second Opinion engagement when you sign within 48 hours.

Turnaround

Standard · 30 days from countersignature of the engagement letter. Included in the flat fee.

Expedited · 14 days · +$2,000. For deadlines on the calendar that the standard turnaround would miss.

Rush · 7 days · +$3,500. For mediations, depositions, or hearings within a tight window.

Expedited and Rush are flat-fee upcharges disclosed and agreed at the consultation. They are not hourly. Faster lanes require all materials at countersignature and are subject to capacity. If a deadline is already on your calendar, flag it at the consultation and I will tell you which lane fits, or if due to time constraints I will not be able to provide you with the service.

Conflict-free, by design

Every other attorney evaluating your case has a financial incentive to find problems they can solve by litigating for you. The Second Opinion is built so that incentive does not exist.

I do not litigate. I do not appear in court. I do not become counsel of record on any matter I have given a Second Opinion on. I do not accept transfers from Second Opinion clients. The flat fee is the entire fee.

That structural independence is the entire point of the engagement. A second set of eyes that has no other agenda is the one worth listening to.


What recent Second Opinion clients walked away with

Miami-Dade · Custody · mid-complexity

Identified three procedural issues counsel had not raised. Client used the report at mediation. Matter resolved within 60 days.

Broward · Post-judgment modification · mid-complexity

Independent strategic read on relocation posture. Client proceeded to mediation with the written report in hand.

Miami-Dade · Strategy risk intensive · Bespoke

Full attorney’s re-read of a 400+ entry docket spanning multi-front motion practice, business valuation, and contested parenting. Written report flagged exposure points and sequencing the prior strategy had not surfaced.

Anonymized engagement summaries. The Florida Bar restricts what attorneys may publish about prior results. These reflect individual matters and do not predict the outcome of any future case. A second opinion report is a professional opinion assessment of your case and no guarantees are made on the results you or your attorney may obtain.


Common questions

A Second Opinion is a fixed, flat-fee written read on the strategy you are already paying for. No transition. No retainer with me for ongoing work. No change of counsel of record. Your current lawyer stays your lawyer. The most common outcome is that you keep your lawyer and bring back a sharper set of questions.

Not from me. The review is private. I do not contact your lawyer, your spouse's lawyer, or the court. What you do with the written report is entirely your decision.

Yes. Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 02-5 directly addresses this. A Florida attorney may give a second opinion to someone already represented by other counsel, including an opinion on how that current lawyer is handling the case.

No. I do not appear at hearings, do not contact opposing counsel, and do not become counsel of record. The work is independent advisory only.

Yes, through Private Counsel, which is the monthly behind-the-scenes engagement. We discuss whether that fits at the debrief call.

We identify the documents at the consultation based on the scope. Typically financial affidavits, the proposed marital settlement agreement, the parenting plan, and the key discovery. You upload after the engagement letter is signed.

Yes. A presuit Second Opinion is one of the strongest moves in a Florida divorce, because your leverage is highest before you sign or file anything. The same engagement structure applies.

Self-represented Floridians are an important part of who this work is for. The written report is built to be usable without an attorney of record.

What clients say

In their own words.

Best money I could have spent!! I kept noticing that my case was getting more and more problematic, more expensive. A friend recommended Aliette. I learned she wasn't litigating anymore but she gave me a comprehensive second opinion report. I didn't tell my lawyer about it. I learned that I am in charge of my case so I told him what I wanted based on what Aliette told me. It's not over yet but it's like we turned down the temperature of the case. I saved twice as much as I paid Aliette and emotionally I feel more at peace.
Carmen, May 2025

Verified client. Published with permission. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Begin

The Second Opinion engagement begins at the consultation.

Miami-Dade based and Florida statewide · English & Spanish · Monthly intake is capped · The $695 consultation credits in full toward the Second Opinion engagement signed within 48 hours

The Second Opinion is an advisory engagement. It does not include court appearances, does not constitute counsel-of-record representation, and does not authorize me to communicate with opposing counsel or appear in your matter. An attorney-client relationship for the Second Opinion engagement is established only by a separate signed engagement letter. Aliette Hernandez Carolan is licensed to practice law in Florida only.